Posts

Stone Lifting and 'Tradition', Part 2: A Discussion with Lifter ‘D.N.’

Image
Stone Lifting and 'Tradition', Part 2: A Discussion with Lifter ‘D.N.’ A discussion with lifter ‘D.N.’ helped distinguish several issues that can easily become tangled together. He explained that lifting a stone within its historical context is what he personally enjoys: travelling to the place and attempting the established challenge is part of its appeal. He questioned my description of that choice as arbitrary or cherry-picked, and made clear that his preference does not mean everyone else must lift identically. He accepted alternative approaches while noting that something like shouldering a carrying stone attracts additional scrutiny and requires appropriate preparation and protection. My concern was both with that reasoning and with how these opinions affect other lifters. In the reactions I have observed, a traditional Húsafell carry ending with the stone dumped from chest height appears to attract far less criticism than a safely controlled shoulder. Meanwhile, I have n...

The Problem With “Traditional Lift Only” in Historic Stone Lifting

Image
The Problem With “Traditional Lift Only” in Historic Stone Lifting There is a phrase that keeps appearing in stone lifting circles: “honour the traditional lift”. On the surface, it sounds reasonable. Respect the stone, its history and the people who came before us. I agree with all of that. The problem begins when “tradition” becomes a fixed rule or a reason to shame other lifters. There is no single Scottish “traditional lift”. The surviving record contains local customs, oral traditions, Victorian retellings, disputed accounts and modern reconstructions. Depending on the stone, the challenge might have involved lifting it to the knee, lap, breast or shoulder, carrying it, loading it onto a wall or plinth, or throwing it over a dyke. So when someone says “only lift it in the traditional manner”, which tradition do they mean, and how do they know? Age alone does not make a practice sensible or responsible. Treating it as sufficient justification is an appeal to tradition. Hobsbawm and...

Different Lifting Styles in Scottish Stone Lifting - The Flawed Notion of One “Traditional” Scottish Lift

Image
Different Lifting Styles in Scottish Stone Lifting - The Flawed Notion of One “Traditional” Scottish Lift Introduction Scottish stone lifting was never one fixed thing. The surviving evidence points to a range of local practices: raising a stone just clear of the ground, lifting it to the knee, lap, chest or shoulder, carrying it, placing it onto another object, or throwing it. Much of this tradition was local and oral, and only partly written down. That makes claims about one “true” Scottish lifting style difficult to sustain. Different stones, communities and local memories shaped what counted as a meaningful lift. The examples below draw on historical accounts, collected folklore and later research, particularly Peter Martin’s work. These sources do not all carry the same evidential weight. A named feat recorded in a clan history, a description of a local custom and a heroic folktale tell us different things. Where an older account is presented through a later writer, that relations...

The Ardvorlich Stone Shouldered - 152kg / 335lbs / 24 stone - A Stone Lifter's Journey

Image
The Ardvorlich Stone Shouldered - 152kg / 335lbs / 24 stone Ardvorlich Stone (Andy Crawford -  4th person to shoulder the Ardvorlich Stone) When I started my stone lifting journey around four years ago (2019)  I had never heard of the Scottish historic stones. The only stones I'd heard of were the Dinnie Stones, so I decided to train to lift them .  This process was hampered by the Covid-19 lockdowns, but as a result I managed to not only lift them, but beat my target of a 5 second unassisted lift.  I ended up holding them for around 18 second.  I went back for a second lift with no equipment and in a shirt and tie, one of a handful of people to do this: So, that was that.  I had achieved my goal and smashed my targets.  I also raised over £500 for cancer research UK, many thanks to all those who sponsored me! 'What next?'  Was the question on my mind and, also, something many of my friends and family were asking.  I did some research online ...