Posts

Showing posts from November, 2026

Stone Lifting and 'Tradition', Part 2: A Discussion with Lifter ‘D.N.’

Image
Stone Lifting and 'Tradition', Part 2: A Discussion with Lifter ‘D.N.’ A discussion with lifter ‘D.N.’ helped distinguish several issues that can easily become tangled together. He explained that lifting a stone within its historical context is what he personally enjoys: travelling to the place and attempting the established challenge is part of its appeal. He questioned my description of that choice as arbitrary or cherry-picked, and made clear that his preference does not mean everyone else must lift identically. He accepted alternative approaches while noting that something like shouldering a carrying stone attracts additional scrutiny and requires appropriate preparation and protection. My concern was both with that reasoning and with how these opinions affect other lifters. In the reactions I have observed, a traditional Húsafell carry ending with the stone dumped from chest height appears to attract far less criticism than a safely controlled shoulder. Meanwhile, I have n...