Stone Lifting and 'Tradition', Part 2: A Discussion with Lifter ‘D.N.’

Stone Lifting and 'Tradition', Part 2: A Discussion with Lifter ‘D.N.’


A discussion with lifter ‘D.N.’ helped distinguish several issues that can easily become tangled together. He explained that lifting a stone within its historical context is what he personally enjoys: travelling to the place and attempting the established challenge is part of its appeal. He questioned my description of that choice as arbitrary or cherry-picked, and made clear that his preference does not mean everyone else must lift identically. He accepted alternative approaches while noting that something like shouldering a carrying stone attracts additional scrutiny and requires appropriate preparation and protection.

My concern was both with that reasoning and with how these opinions affect other lifters. In the reactions I have observed, a traditional Húsafell carry ending with the stone dumped from chest height appears to attract far less criticism than a safely controlled shoulder. Meanwhile, I have not seen comparable outrage when someone safely presses the Dalwhinnie, despite that also departing from its historical challenge. If preservation is the principle, why should the controlled lift attract greater condemnation? If historical fidelity is the principle, why is deviation accepted so readily elsewhere? D.N. argued that differences in condition, setting and history justify assessing stones individually. That is fair, but those differences need to explain the objection. Simply calling one a 'carrying stone' does not establish that a particular carry treats it more carefully than a particular shoulder. Where the same people accept one departure from tradition but scrutise, or go further and condemn, another lifter solely for being 'untraditional', that is a double standard and, to my mind, cherry-picking. D.N. and I indirectly agreed to disagree somewhat on that point. These comparisons are why I remain unconvinced that preservation fully explains the objections to 'untradational lifting'.

There are practical consequences too. I regularly receive questions from lifters asking whether shouldering or pressing is "allowed", with some even asking whether it is “illegal”. When personal opinions are presented as rules and used to shame responsible lifters into compliance, that is gatekeeping. I find this outrageous, and I will “die on that hill”: nobody should be intimidated out of a careful, permitted lift simply because someone else dislikes its supposed departure from tradition.

Several others have asked whether clasping is frowned upon or considered cheating. These are my own experiences, rather than a survey of the community, but they show how strongly expressed preferences can be understood as rules. I have also seen a lifter remove a post and withdraw from public discussion following criticism of an alternative/'untradional' lift. I cannot attribute that decision to any one person or comment, but it illustrates my concern about the pressure these exchanges can create. People can end up limiting what they attempt or share because they expect condemnation, even when they intend to lift carefully and respectfully. A personal preference carries a different weight when others present it as the only acceptable approach.

D.N.’s position deserves distinguishing from the more forceful/unconsidered/unthoughful attitudes I am describing. During our discussion, I acknowledged that my use of 'stone police' (in jest, I might add, and certainly without venom or bile) on a recent post had grouped together people with similar views, and I apologised for mistaken assumptions about his involvement in criticism of another lifter to the point of 'witch hunting'. We ultimately agreed on permission, physical preparation, protection for the stone and site, and planning for lowering or failure. Our different emphases on 'tradition' remained, alongside a shared commitment to preserving the stones. For me, that commitment should also leave room for lifters to explore responsible alternatives without being made to feel that they are doing something inherently wrong.

Scottish Historical Stone Lifting: A Code of Conduct

My approach to historical Scottish stone lifting is guided by four simple principles:

  • Respect the stone. Historical lifting stones are important pieces of Scotland’s cultural heritage, not disposable gym equipment. Avoid unnecessary impacts, uncontrolled drops and practices that risk damaging or altering them.

  • Respect the place. Protect the surrounding environment, historic structures and property. Respect local access arrangements and leave the site as you found it, ensuring future generations can enjoy these places.

  • Understand the history. Take time to learn about each stone, its origins, local traditions and historical significance. Recognise that Scottish stone lifting was never governed by one universal lifting style, and that different stones and communities had different traditions.

  • Lift within your ability. Exercise good judgement, control and an understanding of your own limitations. A carefully controlled lift, regardless of style, is preferable to an uncontrolled attempt that risks damaging the stone, its surroundings or the lifter.

Historical precedent does not automatically justify repeating every practice today. Just because a stone was once thrown, loaded onto old masonry or carried into a building does not mean such practices remain appropriate.

Tradition should guide modern Scottish stone lifting, but never at the expense of preservation, safety or respect for our shared heritage. Ultimately, our responsibility is not simply to lift these stones, but to ensure they remain available for generations of lifters yet to come.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Ardvorlich Stone Shouldered - 152kg / 335lbs / 24 stone - A Stone Lifter's Journey

The Problem With “Traditional Lift Only” in Historic Stone Lifting

Different Lifting Styles in Scottish Stone Lifting - The Flawed Notion of One “Traditional” Scottish Lift